Д-р Стаменов написа:
Нека тези, които не ползват ултразвук за активиране да си направят извода за движението на разтвора, което той създава и ефекта му пък бил той и статистически незначителен!
Добре проведените научни изследвания са рядкост и затова още по - голяма чест прави на авторите/ колегите, които коректно правят публични резултатите от тях, въпреки че те не показват съществено предимство за апаратите създадени от същите тези автори.
/ даже спрямо ръчната активация на разтворите с помоща на гута перчов щифт ! /
ABSTRACT
Aim:
The aim of this study was to compare, under the scanning electron microscope (SEM), the efficacy of the EndoActivator to passive ultrasonic irrigation (PUI), using ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), on smear layer and debris removal at the apical portions of curved root canals.
Methodology:
Forty-five extracted maxillary teeth with curved root canals were randomly distributed into 3 test groups. All teeth were prepared using ProFile rotary instruments and subjected to different final irrigation regimes; group A, 17% EDTA without sonics or ultrasonics; group B, 17% EDTA with sonics (EndoActivator); and group C, 17% EDTA with ultrasonics. The teeth were split in half, sectioned longitudinally and prepared for viewing under a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Samples were examined under SEM and scored for debris
and smear layer removal.
Results:
At the 2 mm level from the apical foramen, specimens from Group B and C scored significantly better than Group A for debris removal (p < 0.05).
There was no significant difference in terms of smear score for all 3 groups at the 2 mm and 6 mm level.
Conclusions:
Within the limitations of this study, a one-minute use of the EndoActivator with 17% EDTA was as efficient as ultrasonics in removing debris in the apical regions of the curved root canals.
A one minute application of EDTA in curved root canals is not effective in the removal of smear layer, even when the EndoActivator or ultrasonics was used.
Chye (National University Hospital Singapore) November 2008
Studies on EndoActivator – Prof.Machtou
Assessment of irrigant activation efficiency in the apical third of curved canals: a scanning electron microscopic study
G. Caron1, K. Nham2, F. Bronnec1 & P. Machtou1
1 Department of Endodontics and Restorative Dentistry, Garanciere School of Dentistry,
University of Paris 7, Paris, France; 2 Department of Surface Physico-Chemistry, UMR7045, ENSCP, Paris, France
Aim: To investigate, via SEM observations, three activation devices for root canal irrigants after root canal preparation and assess the importance of this final step before obturation
Methodology: Sixty-eight
curved canals from freshly extracted mandibular molars used for this study were divided into 3 groups with four control teeth. All teeth were prepared with Protaper Universal® rotary files and appropriate irrigation. Each test group was then flushed
with 1 ml of EDTA (17%) and 3 ml of sodium hypochlorite (3%). In group 1,
both irrigants were activated with the gutta-percha master cone. In group 2, activation was achieved with RinsEndo®. In group 3, each irrigant was activated with a recent device: the Endoactivator®.
All teeth were split with a novel approach to allow visualization of every third of the canal, particularly the apical third. The samples were prepared for SEM observation to assess the root canal cleanliness involving assessment of smear layer removal. Scoring was done in
blinded fashion by two calibrated observers according to a five-score scale.
Results:
Each apical third sample showed very high levels of cleanliness (≤ score 3). Sonic activation was significantly more effective than automated-dynamic irrigation (p=0.006), but there was no significant difference between sonic activation and manual-dynamic activation
(p=0.177).
Automated-dynamic irrigation was less effective in removing smear layer than manual-dynamic activation, but the difference was not significant (p=0.85).
Arthur Dent написа :
Днес прелекувах долен 6-ти, лекуван преди 20 години - 4 канала, некротични, но недокоснати от човешки ръце, перфорирана фуркация, затворена с...Форедент!?!?!, субгингивален, 2мм дефект, пломбиран с нечовешко количество амалгама....
и всичко това - без никаква обективна и субективна симптоматика, без периапикални изменения, без загуба на кост във фуркацията... НИЩО!!! Просто амалгамата се беше счупила и "дереше" езика на пациентката..)
Коректните научни изследвания и случаи като описания по-горе ( които аз лично, а сигурно и всички колеги виждаме поне 2-3 пъти седмично ) показват ясно кой е най-важният фактор определящ
поне засега крайният клиничен резултат от едно кореново лечение.